Our Story

Meet the Founders Sarah Michler & Caroline Witmer

Sarah and Caroline are childhood friends who grew up spending their summers on Nantucket, a charming island off the coast of Massachusetts. As seasons turned and responsibilities grew, they found themselves yearning for those simple, carefree days by the sea. With an unquenchable passion for all things sweet, Sarah and Caroline set out to create Tuck Shop after their favorite little chocolate shop closed down on the island.

Tuck Shop is a combination of friendship, travel and timeless details — where artisanal chocolates meet cherished destinations. Each meticulously crafted chocolate bar captures the essence of your happy place. More than a treat, Tuck Shop is a taste of nostalgia, a reminder that the sweetest things in life are often worth savoring.

Indulge in a moment of joy, share a piece with loved ones, or discover a new happy place with every bite. Follow along as we curate a collection of destinations, each wrapped in a taste of pure delight.

Behind Our Name

An ode to the tiny island of Nantucket off the coast of Massachusetts and a play on the British name for confectionary shops.

Shop Our Collections